Separating the Theological Sheep from the Philosophical Goats

Authors

  • Jonathan Curtis Rutledge

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.12978/jat.2021-1.3540-39434630

Abstract

Andrew Torrance has recently argued that we can distinguish analytic theology from analytic philosophy of religion if we understand theology as, fundamentally, a scientific enterprise. However, this distinction holds only if philosophy of religion is not itself a science in the sense intended by Torrance. I argue that philosophy of religion is a science in this sense, and so, that Torrance cannot distinguish theology from philosophy of religion in the way suggested. Nevertheless, I offer two alternative routes to the distinction based on the nature of the respective objects of study in theology and philosophy of religion. Thus, I demonstrate that there is a coherent model available to Torrance which preserves the distinction he seeks.

Downloads

Published

2021-09-22

Issue

Section

Articles